
Saturday, June 27, 2009
They wobble, but they don't fall down.

Tuesday, January 13, 2009
Auction estimate or insurance value?
I love the Antiques Roadshow.
Others have chided me for this adoration. They think that the long-running PBS production (which, like most good American television, was co-opted from British TV) is a warhorse of a program... an old fart's show. All I hear is "Girl, why are you watching that crap?" and "Turn that shit off and put on American Idol."
No. I'm not turning it off. I love the Roadshow. I love watching the new episodes. I love watching the re-runs. I love watching the commercials advertising new episodes and re-runs. And I'm not alone. The show is returning to Madison several years after its previous visit to our city, and the 6,000 available tickets sold out within 30 minutes. The Roadshow is clearly a covert favorite... a secret pleasure hidden away from public scrutiny much in the same way homosexual desire was concealed not so long ago.
Is loving the Roadshow the new gay? Is loving the Roadshow the "love that dare not speak its name"?
The Roadshow is a wonderful combination of several delicious qualities of human nature. It's very much an everyman phenomenon. The people who bring their family heirlooms and garage sale treasures are not the fabulous jet-set types whom one would naturally expect to own such baubles. They are most certainly among the hoi polloi, which allows the viewer... any viewer... to identify with them much more immediately and intimately. The celebration of average people as being caretakers of extraordinary things is a rarity among reality shows (of which the Roadshow is most certainly one). The "Real Housewives" and the Kardashians are occasionally interesting to watch in a slow-down-next-to-the-horrible-car-accident kind of way, but one doesn't really identify with them. With the Roadshow, it's personal.
Most families have a collection of special items that are passed down through the generations. The American concept of history is a murky one, with our historical memory too often being restricted to pundits and cherry-picked sound bytes. Tangible heirlooms provide an immediate and unmistakable connection between present company and the ancestral past. In a country that celebrates the new and shiny, a program that shows the value of the ancient and dingy is a welcome aberration.
And if you want something that's craven and prurient, the Roadshow has that for you as well. The very best of segments fall into one of two categories: the unexpectedly high valuation, and the unexpectedly low valuation.
The former category is characterized by shrieks of surprised delight followed occasionally by tears. The tears are often the result of the current owner thinking back to his fixed income grandmother's tiny house in the country, in which a much-beloved object was interwoven into the fabric of the family's memory without realization of the market value of the piece. This is the best kind of art... pieces that are lived with... things that are quietly and elegantly present during the daily lives of the owners without regard for the auction estimates.
The latter category is a guilty favorite. Occasionally, one observes an owner of an object whose entire sense of self is fractured when the appraiser informs them that Aunt Tillie's beautiful priceless vase from the Ming dynasty is instead a plastic piece of crap made in Korea in 1982. The stunned silence after the appraiser utters the auction estimate is laden with confusion and denial, and is absolutely one of the best sources of Schadenfreude on the planet.
What would you bring to the Roadshow for valuation? I would likely bring a collection of old kerosene lamps that my grandmother gave me. They're not likely very expensive... she wasn't a wealthy woman... but she was an antiques dealer in Rochester, NY and had a very keen eye for collectibles. I would like to know more about the lamps... where the came from and how they were originally used. Of course I could never sell them. Grandmother wouldn't have allowed that.